Giving moviegoers the most accurate picture of movie reviews possible
NANNY MCPHEE RETURNS Movie Reviews
Story: Family comedy about a magical nanny who turns up to help a mother, whose husband is away at war, contend with her children and their spoiled cousins. Cast: Emma Thompson, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Rhys Ifans, Maggie Smith, Asa Butterfield Director: Susanna White Opened: August 20, 2010 On DVD: December 14, 2010 From: Universal Rating: PG Length: 1 hr. 49 min.
Out On DVD
DECEMBER 14, 2010
Nanny McPhee Returns, Good (Not Great) Reviews
Updated: Fri, Mar 2 2012, 06:38pm
Digg This StumbleUpon del.icio.us Twitter Share on Facebook
 | E-Mail to a Friend  | Print 

Nanny McPhee Returns played to good not great reviews. • Kristin Tillotson wrote in the Minneapolis Star-Tribune, "Thanks to star Emma Thompson's smart, appealing script, the mysterious baby sitter with the grotesque face and no-nonsense ways once again delivers a welcome antidote to Disneyfied heroines." • And MaryAnn Johanson wrote for Flick Filosopher, "...more for the kiddies... But it’s hardly a chore to sit through as an adult, either."  More Reviews Below...

Nanny McPhee Returns
Positive Reviews
(37 Reviews,  reviews below)
 Compare This Movie... 
TotalBroad
National
Press
Local
News-
papers
Alter–
native/
Indie
High-
Brow
Press
Movie
Industry
NY/LA
Chicago
Toronto
Key
Cities
Total
B.O.
63.2% 70.1% 63.3% 45.1% 43.6% 54.3% 56.2% 71.2% $29.0M
Averages: 51.8% 54.1% 52.3% 46.9% 45.8% 48.7% 49.9% 54.7%
Reviews & Quotes (37)

BROAD NATIONAL PRESS (5 Reviews)
Alynda Wheat, People: VERY GOOD (cg)
"This time she's teaching the Greens to coexist with their spoiled visiting relatives... The effects are cute..." (Read the full review...)
143 words, 08/19/10

Jake Coyle, Associated Press: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"...one can quibble only so much with a family friendly film that so brightly preaches those not-exactly-hip tenets of country living and manners." (Read the full review...)
780 words, 08/19/10

Thelma Adams, Us Weekly: VERY GOOD (cg)
"The charming family film is best when the magic prevails: Piglets do synchronized swimming and naughty children spank themselves!" (Read the full review...)
50 words, 08/19/10

Lisa Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly: GOOD (cg)
"Kid viewers will have fun with the references to barnyard poo, poo of all sorts, poo to reckon with." (Read the full review...)
107 words, 08/13/10

Claudia Puig, USA Today: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"...entertaining... the kind of unruly mess you can't imagine the indomitable 'Nanny McPhee' tolerating." (Read the full review...)
544 words, 08/20/10
we have an app for when you're out and about
get our iPhone app...     get our mobile web app...
movie     review     intelligence
NEW YORK/LOS ANGELES/CHICAGO/TORONTO (12 Reviews)
Mike Hale, New York Times: MODERATE
"...forsakes the menacing air and psychedelic color scheme of the original for a broader comic tone and a sunny, gold-flecked palette." (Read the full review...)
638 words, 08/20/10

Joe Neumaier, New York Daily News: POOR (cg)
"...this dour, hyperactive family film is joyless, overly busy and starchy. Worse, it pats itself on the back for doling out the most minimal of morals." (Read the full review...)
441 words, 08/20/10

Glenn Whipp, Los Angeles Times: VERY GOOD
"...tells a slightly different story but uses the same blend of broad comedy, respectful moralizing and special effects that made the first film a success.... It's a fairy tale in the best tradition." (Read the full review...)
406 words, 08/20/10

Lou Lumenick, New York Post: MODERATE (cg)
"...an overlong and overproduced sequel to the dimly recalled 2005 family flick written by and starring Emma Thompson as the poor kid's Mary Poppins..." (Read the full review...)
332 words, 08/20/10

Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune: MODERATE (cg)
"...more pushy than charming... shrill, laden with routine computer-generated effects and pounded into dust by James Newton Howard's shut-up-already musical score." (Read the full review...)
536 words, 08/20/10

Rafer Guzman, New York Newsday: VERY GOOD (cg)
"A near copy of the original, but still a funny and charming family film." (Read the full review...)
313 words, 08/20/10

Bill Zwecker, Chicago Sun-Times: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...just the ticket to a totally enjoyable fantasy romp." (Read the full review...)
519 words, 08/20/10

Nick Schager, Village Voice/LA Weekly: WEAK
"Thompson's intimidating caregiver is a charmless snooze.... merely a compendium of photocopied elements, cartoonish special effects, and easy-bake happily-ever-afters." (Read the full review...)
201 words, 08/18/10

Bruce DeMara, Toronto Star: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...sure to delight kids but grown-up enough to delight, well, grown ups." (Read the full review...)
379 words, 08/20/10

Liam Lacey, Toronto Globe & Mail: VERY GOOD (cg)
"Kids should revel in the warts, choreographed pigs and animal poo. Their parents will endure these things stoically and occasionally chuckle, which seems the traditional English thing to do." (Read the full review...)
522 words, 08/20/10

Norman Wilner, Toronto Now: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"It's essentially the same 'Nanny McPhee' movie all over again.... may be disposable entertainment, but it's still entertaining." (Read the full review...)
342 words, 08/20/10
KEY CITIES (12 Reviews)
Stephanie Merry, Washington Post: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"It can take a miracle to create a movie that's fun for kids and their parents.... there's plenty in 'Nanny McPhee Returns' to keep everyone entertained for the surprisingly fleeting 108 minutes." (Read the full review...)
455 words, 08/20/10

Carrie Rickey, Philadelphia Inquirer: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...strikes a nice balance between slapstick and earned sentimentality. The movie warms the heart without using schmaltz to fuel its fire.... the actors are a joy..." (Read the full review...)
410 words, 08/20/10

Mick LaSalle, Houston Chronicle/San Francisco Chronicle: VERY GOOD (cg)
"The original 'Nanny McPhee' may have been a slightly better movie in most of its particulars, but the sequel can put tears in your eyes, and that's no small thing." (Read the full review...)
659 words, 08/20/10

Roger Moore, Orlando Sentinel: VERY GOOD (cg)
"Sweet, sentimental, silly and star-studded... one of the best children's movies of the year, a fairytale stressed-out parents won't mind sharing with their little darlings." (Read the full review...)
561 words, 08/20/10

Kristin Tillotson, Minneapolis Star-Tribune: OUTSTANDING (cg)
"Thanks to star Emma Thompson's smart, appealing script, the mysterious baby sitter with the grotesque face and no-nonsense ways once again delivers a welcome antidote to Disneyfied heroines." (Read the full review...)
311 words, 08/20/10

Bill Goodykoontz, Arizona Republic: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...old-school without seeming old-fashioned, a familiar tale of lessons learned (it is a sequel, after all) made unapologetically for children and all the better for it." (Read the full review...)
541 words, 08/20/10

Nancy Churnin, Dallas Morning News: EXCELLENT (cg)
"...has charm, magic and Emma Thompson - and that's more than you can say about a lot of family films." (Read the full review...)
618 words, 08/20/10

Tom Russo, Boston Globe: MODERATE (cg)
"...disappointing... we get a gentler, more wink-inclined Nanny McPhee, not to mention kids whose rambunctiousness seems manufactured rather than entertainingly exaggerated." (Read the full review...)
541 words, 08/20/10

Moira Macdonald, Seattle Times: VERY GOOD (cg)
"She's no scene-stealing Mary Poppins, but very much a background figure, quietly using magic to help the children realize what's right.... May Nanny McPhee return again, very soon." (Read the full review...)
401 words, 08/20/10

Charles Williams, St. Louis Post-Dispatch: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...a delightful family movie, filled with frolicking farm animals, flying motorcycles and life lessons worth remembering." (Read the full review...)
234 words, 08/20/10

Adam Graham, Detroit News: MODERATE (cg)
"The presence of Thompson lends 'Nanny McPhee Returns' a pedigree it ultimately doesn't live up to." (Read the full review...)
295 words, 08/20/10
ALTERNATIVE/INDIE PRESS (9 Reviews)
Nick Schager, Village Voice/LA Weekly: WEAK
"Thompson's intimidating caregiver is a charmless snooze.... merely a compendium of photocopied elements, cartoonish special effects, and easy-bake happily-ever-afters." (Read the full review...)
201 words, 08/18/10

Tom Meek, Boston Phoenix: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"At least the A-list cast and crisp direction by TV vet Susanna White lift the film out of the dung heap." (Read the full review...)
149 words, 08/26/10

Scott Tobias, AV Club: WEAK (cg)
"...built on a bedrock of poo jokes, hairy moles, and gooey substances that stick to characters' shoes." (Read the full review...)
357 words, 08/19/10

Joe Utichi, Cinematical: MODERATE
"...it'll just about keep parents entertained as well as kids, and even in a family marketplace as saturated as this, that's a rare bit of magic." (Read the full review...)
722 words, 08/20/10

Simon Abrams, Slant: WEAK (cg)
"...too self-conscious to ever take off.... jokes are so strained and eager to please that they fail to earn more than a scanty chuckle here and there..." (Read the full review...)
755 words, 08/19/10

Norman Wilner, Toronto Now: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"It's essentially the same 'Nanny McPhee' movie all over again.... may be disposable entertainment, but it's still entertaining." (Read the full review...)
342 words, 08/20/10

Curt Holman, Atlanta Creative Loafing: WEAK (cg)
"Flatulence drowns out the life lessons in unwelcome sequel to charming original.... the film's shrill tone, tedious overacting and cheap, gouge-your-eyes-out CGI effects lack any magic whatsoever." (Read the full review...)
594 words, 08/20/10

MaryAnn Johanson, Flick Filosopher: EXCELLENT (cg)
"...more for the kiddies... But it's hardly a chore to sit through as an adult, either. The brighter, lighter silliness of this sequel may be kindergarten comedy, but it doesn't overwhelm the more pertinent points about learning to be generous, cooperative, and kind..." (Read the full review...)
701 words, 08/19/10
HIGHBROW PRESS (3 Reviews)
Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal: POOR
"...the plot is merely a pretext for such specially labored effects as a burping crow and synchro-swimming piglets. The ham-handed director was Susanna White, who intercuts compulsively, whether or not anything is happening." (Read the full review...)
264 words, 08/20/10

Mike Hale, New York Times: MODERATE
"...forsakes the menacing air and psychedelic color scheme of the original for a broader comic tone and a sunny, gold-flecked palette." (Read the full review...)
638 words, 08/20/10

Glenn Whipp, Los Angeles Times: VERY GOOD
"...tells a slightly different story but uses the same blend of broad comedy, respectful moralizing and special effects that made the first film a success.... It's a fairy tale in the best tradition." (Read the full review...)
406 words, 08/20/10
MOVIE INDUSTRY (4 Reviews)
Kirk Honeycutt, Hollywood Reporter: GOOD
"...a welcome reappearance for children and a fanciful wish fulfillment for harried parents who can only yearn for such a child minder." (Read the full review...)
936 words, 08/19/10

Glenn Whipp, Los Angeles Times: VERY GOOD
"...tells a slightly different story but uses the same blend of broad comedy, respectful moralizing and special effects that made the first film a success.... It's a fairy tale in the best tradition." (Read the full review...)
406 words, 08/20/10

Mike Hale, New York Times: MODERATE
"...forsakes the menacing air and psychedelic color scheme of the original for a broader comic tone and a sunny, gold-flecked palette." (Read the full review...)
638 words, 08/20/10

Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal: POOR
"...the plot is merely a pretext for such specially labored effects as a burping crow and synchro-swimming piglets. The ham-handed director was Susanna White, who intercuts compulsively, whether or not anything is happening." (Read the full review...)
264 words, 08/20/10
(cg) = based on the critic's grade

Review Mixture
19.6 Percentage Points Average Difference Between Reviews
(Norm is 18.4pp; <18.4pp = More Consistent; >18.4pp = More Mixed)

Nanny McPhee Returns's reviews are separated by an average 19.6 percentage points. The norm for this measure is 18.4 percentage points. Less than 18.4 indicates more consistent reviews; greater than 18.4 indicates more mixed reviews. In the chart below, each dot represents a review, with the dots at the top more positive than the dots at the bottom. From left to right, the dots represent reviews in big, bigger and biggest publications. Roll over each dot for more detail.

Nanny McPhee Returns
(37 reviews)
Roll over dots for each review
Broad National   Alternative/Indie   Highbrow Press   Key Cities
NY, LA, Chicago, & Toronto Movie Industry  
Outstanding
Very Good
Good
Moderate
Weak
Poor
Reviews
Outstanding
Very Good
Good
Moderate
Weak
Poor
Reviews
Big
Publications
>Bigger
Publications
>Biggest
Publications
Coverage, Volume & Length

Coverage: Nanny McPhee Returns's reviews cover 67.8% of potential readers (average is 68.2%). Volume: The film's reviews total 16,636 words in volume (average is 19,979 words). Length: The film's reviews average 450 words in length (the norm is 512 words).

Nanny McPhee Returns
Coverage, Volume & Length
(37 Reviews,  reviews below)
TotalBroad
National
Press
Local
News-
papers
Alter–
native/
Indie
High-
Brow
Press
Movie
Industry
NY/LA
Chicago
Toronto
Key
Cities
Total
B.O.
Coverage:
Volume:
Length:
67.8%
16,636
450
65.5%
1,624
325
89.5%
9,799
467
86.0%
4,013
446
52.2%
1,308
436
66.7%
2,244
561
90.6%
4,821
402
81.1%
5,713
476
$29.0M
Averages: 68.2%
19,979
512
66.7%
3,178
451
80.2%
10,677
521
80.8%
3,310
430
58.7%
2,374
630
85.2%
3,407
685
83.7%
5,861
500
73.0%
2,885
539
Opening Day Reviews
Reviews Broke 25.2 Hours Before Release (Norm is 0.2 Release)

Nanny McPhee Returns's reviews on average broke 25.2 hours before opening. Norm for this measure is 0.2 hours after. The chart below shows reviews on opening day and the days before and after opening; the left side is earlier and the right side is later. The red bars extending above the horizontal mid-line represent more positive reviews, and the red bars extending below represent more negative reviews. The white space/red bar in the middle is Nanny McPhee Returns's opening day. Click on any bar for a list of the reviews for that day.

Nanny McPhee Returns
(37 reviews, click on bars for reviews)
M O R E    P O S I T I V E    R E V I E W S
E
A
R
L
I
E
R
L
A
T
E
R
M O R E    N E G A T I V E    R E V I E W S
Movie Review Intelligence Mobile Web App 1.0
Updated: Fri, Mar 2 2012, 06:38pm
Digg This StumbleUpon del.icio.us Twitter Share on Facebook
 | E-Mail to a Friend  | Print 


Mobile Web App version 1.0 shows a list of all current movies and review information. You can click through to the cast, director, synopsis, release date and rating on page two, plus individual reviews on page three. The information is updated on a live/real-time basis. You can also search our database of films. Designed for when you're on the move and want the latest info, this app will work on any mobile web browser.

From your mobile device -- only from a mobile device -- open our Mobile Web App here...





A


 

 

 

get one email
Update
every Friday when
the reviews are in
GO
Ongoing Wide
  Releases
(Limiteds Below)
Ongoing Limited
  Releases
(Wides Above)