Giving moviegoers the most accurate picture of movie reviews possible
Home
Out on DVD
Search Movies
Compare Movies
Critics
Publications
About Us
Dear Reader: Update, Movie Review Intelligence will
continue publishing this website through June (more...)
Search a Movie:
SHERLOCK HOLMES: A GAME OF SHADOWS Movie Reviews
Action adventure about Sherlock Holmes' pursuit of Professor Moriarty, a criminal mastermind with an evil plan that could change the course of history. Cast: Robert Downey Jr., Jude Law, Noomi Rapace, Jared Harris, Rachel McAdams Director: Guy Ritchie Release Date: December 16, 2011 DVD Release: June 12, 2012 From: Warner Bros. Rating: PG-13 Length: 2 hr 8 min
Out On DVD
JUNE 12, 2012

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, Mixed Reviews

Updated: Sun, Nov 4 2012, 11:24am
Digg This StumbleUpon del.icio.us Twitter Share on Facebook
 | E-Mail to a Friend  | Print 
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows played to mixed reviews. • Steve Persall wrote in the St. Petersburg Times, "Downey relishes each tic and quirk, and playing the self-anointed smartest guy in any room is second nature by now. He's a joy to watch..." • And Joe Williams wrote in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, "...a second chance to kick a classic character into the gutter."   More Reviews Below...

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
Positive Reviews
(49 Reviews, reviews below)
 Compare This Movie... 
TotalBroad
National
Press
Local
News-
papers
Alter–
native/
Indie
High-
Brow
Press
Movie
Industry
NY/LA
Chicago
Toronto
Key
Cities
Total
B.O.
54.1% 57.8% 54.5% 55.4% 39.5% 55.7% 51.6% 56.6% $186.8M
Averages: 51.7% 54.3% 51.9% 47.1% 45.9% 49.0% 49.7% 54.4%
* 54.1% positive reviews out of 100%

Reviews & Quotes (49)


BROAD NATIONAL PRESS (10 Reviews)

Alynda Wheat, People: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...does anyone have more fun onscreen than Robert Downey Jr.?... makes the most of its leading men and delivers on the action..." (See all of Alynda Wheat's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
334 words, 12/15/11

Richard Corliss, Time: MODERATE
"...replaces the 2009 film's burly energy with frantic incident: bombs, chases and more bombs.... fresh inspiration is sparse here... it's less an extension than a remake." (See all of Richard Corliss's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
1,055 words, 12/16/11

Christy Lemire, Associated Press: WEAK (cg)
"...what seemed clever and novel the first time around now feels stale and tired.... the chemistry just isn't there this time." (See all of Christy Lemire's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
537 words, 12/15/11

Mara Reinstein, Us Weekly: MODERATE (cg)
"Sherlock's mental chess game intrigues... Too bad director Guy Ritchie upends the old-school fun by including a barrage of overly stylized slow-mo fight sequences." (See all of Mara Reinstein's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
81 words, 12/15/11

Owen Gleiberman, Entertainment Weekly: GOOD (cg)
"...darkly nimble yet frictionless... Ritchie, if he wanted, could probably make a classic Holmes caper, but instead he treats Holmes' insights as mere froth." (See all of Owen Gleiberman's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
221 words, 12/30/11

Peter Travers, Rolling Stone: MODERATE (cg)
"...eliminates smarts in favor of relentless headbanging.... the grace notes are drowned out by Ritchie's incessant need to obliterate thought and feeling." (See all of Peter Travers's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
184 words, 12/16/11

Claudia Puig, USA Today: MODERATE (cg)
"...a film that is filled with too many deviations and drunken detours.... simultaneously brash and dull -- hardly a combustible combination." (See all of Claudia Puig's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
496 words, 12/16/11

Roger Ebert, RogerEbert.com: OUTSTANDING (cg)
"...set aside your memories of the Conan Doyle stories, save them to savor on a night this winter and enjoy this movie as a high-caliber entertainment." (See all of Roger Ebert's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
875 words, 12/16/11

Glenn Kenny, MSN Movies: MODERATE (cg)
"As big, loud moviemaking goes it's not quite as devoid of charm as it could have been, and things being as they are these days, that's saying something." (See all of Glenn Kenny's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
679 words, 12/14/11

James Berardinelli, Reel Views: VERY GOOD (cg)
"...a stronger, better realized movie that builds upon the strengths of the original and jettisons some of the weaknesses." (See all of James Berardinelli's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
1,079 words, 12/13/11
we have an app for when you're out and about
get our iPhone app...     or get our mobile web app...
movie     review     intelligence

NEW YORK/LOS ANGELES/CHICAGO/TORONTO (14 Reviews)

A.O. Scott, New York Times: FAIR
"Can a movie be hyperactive and lazy at the same time? Clever and idiotic? If the director is Guy Ritchie, the questions answer themselves." (See all of A.O. Scott's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
497 words, 12/16/11

Joe Neumaier, New York Daily News: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"The subversiveness in 'Game of Shadows' is admirable. You just don't need to be Sherlock to detect that it's lacking vision." (See all of Joe Neumaier's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
419 words, 12/16/11

Betsy Sharkey, Los Angeles Times: GOOD
"...a few shades brighter than its predecessor... closer to the full-throttle 'Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels' mode director Guy Ritchie didn't quite capture the first time." (See all of Betsy Sharkey's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
764 words, 12/16/11

Kyle Smith, New York Post: WEAK (cg)
"...so moron-friendly they should have called it 'Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Checkers.' The skill level in the script is elementary school, my dear Watson." (See all of Kyle Smith's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
822 words, 12/16/11

Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune: POOR (cg)
"...a headache, and, finally, a travesty." (See all of Michael Phillips's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
413 words, 12/16/11

Rafer Guzman, New York Newsday: VERY GOOD (cg)
"Jared Harris' Moriarty jolts Downey's Sherlock to life for the first time; they're a convincing pair of bristling, not-so-gentlemanly adversaries." (See all of Rafer Guzman's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
512 words, 12/16/11

David Edelstein, New York Magazine: WEAK
"Ritchie goes for maximum clutter. His busy, boisterous frames suggest Richard Lester's 'Three Musketeers' films but without Lester's prankishness." (See all of David Edelstein's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
350 words, 12/19/11

Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times: OUTSTANDING (cg)
"...set aside your memories of the Conan Doyle stories, save them to savor on a night this winter and enjoy this movie as a high-caliber entertainment."
(See all of Roger Ebert's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
875 words, 12/16/11

Nick Pinkerton, Village Voice/LA Weekly: FAIR
"Lackluster screenwriting and the absence of actorly communion are breezed past with monotonous banter, as is the fleetingly visible plot." (See all of Nick Pinkerton's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
712 words, 12/14/11

Bruce DeMara, Toronto Star: WEAK (cg)
"...the product of a lazy director who has settled for a poorly conceived, pedestrian script." (See all of Bruce DeMara's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
584 words, 12/16/11

Rick Groen, Toronto Globe & Mail: MODERATE (cg)
"For all their bantering and bosom-buddying, Downey, Jr. and Law somehow lack the one thing they can't do without - chemistry." (See all of Rick Groen's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
678 words, 12/16/11

Josep Parera, La Opinion: WEAK (cg)
"Quizá haya miembros de la misma que, abrumados por el efecto, se dejen engañar y crean haber visto una película.... no es un filme, es un despropósito." (See all of Josep Parera's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
603 words, 12/16/11

Norman Wilner, Toronto Now: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"...shit constantly blows up or catches fire... Downey's still miscast as Holmes, but it's less bothersome this time around because we already know what we're in for." (See all of Norman Wilner's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
174 words, 12/15/11

KEY CITIES (13 Reviews)

Mark Jenkins, Washington Post: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"...draws here and there on Conan Doyle's tales, but it relies more on Hong Kong's hyperactive 1980s new wave, as filtered through 'The Matrix' and Quentin Tarantino." (See all of Mark Jenkins's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
589 words, 12/16/11

Steven Rea, Philadelphia Inquirer: MODERATE (cg)
"...the intellectual side of Downey's Holmes is represented by not much more than show-off blather and far-fetched 'reasoning.' Not a keen mind so much as a careening script." (See all of Steven Rea's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
534 words, 12/16/11

Colin Covert, Minneapolis Star-Tribune: OUTSTANDING (cg)
"...a thing of mad, whirring glee.... the film lampoons the James Bond action template while delivering all the thrills." (See all of Colin Covert's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
542 words, 12/16/11

Bill Goodykoontz, Arizona Republic: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"Downey, Jr. and Law retain the winning chemistry from the first, superior film, and that's enough to make you soldier on through the overly stylized action." (See all of Bill Goodykoontz's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
496 words, 12/16/11

Ty Burr, Boston Globe: MODERATE (cg)
"...the light has gone from the star's eyes and the thrill is gone from this franchise.... we have a movie that keeps selling itself long after the sale has been made." (See all of Ty Burr's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
674 words, 12/16/11

Stephen Whitty, New Jersey Star-Ledger: MODERATE (cg)
"...for those of us whose fondness for Holmes and Watson is more than elementary, this is little fun at all." (See all of Stephen Whitty's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
565 words, 12/16/11

Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle: POOR (cg)
"Guy Ritchie turns Holmes into an action hero, a mumbling mess and a crashing bore, with an English accent that sounds phony even to Americans." (See all of Mick LaSalle's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
693 words, 12/16/11

Moira Macdonald, Seattle Times: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"There's enough fun to be had to justify the ticket price for fans, but just barely. If a third game is afoot, let's hope Ritchie and the rest have a few more ideas up their velvet sleeves." (See all of Moira Macdonald's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
501 words, 12/16/11

Mike Russell, Portland Oregonian: GOOD (cg)
"...has all the merits and demerits of its predecessor, only with a less snarly antagonist, a more thoughtful final showdown and broader Holmes/Watson relationship jokes." (See all of Mike Russell's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
320 words, 12/16/11

Joe Williams, St. Louis Post-Dispatch: WEAK (cg)
"...a second chance to kick a classic character into the gutter.... the most pandering picture of the year? Fo' shizzle, Sherlock." (See all of Joe Williams's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
385 words, 12/16/11

Steve Persall, St. Petersburg Times: EXCELLENT (cg)
"Downey relishes each tic and quirk, and playing the self-anointed smartest guy in any room is second nature by now. He's a joy to watch..." (See all of Steve Persall's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
530 words, 12/15/11

Adam Graham, Detroit News: GOOD (cg)
"...there's something disconcerting about watching Downey Jr. go down this path.... he has become a paycheck chaser, juggling multiple franchises unworthy of his talents." (See all of Adam Graham's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
295 words, 12/16/11

Connie Ogle, Miami Herald: MODERATE (cg)
"Better than the first one, but not by much." (See all of Connie Ogle's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
538 words, 12/16/11

ALTERNATIVE/INDIE PRESS (10 Reviews)

Nick Pinkerton, Village Voice/LA Weekly: FAIR
"Lackluster screenwriting and the absence of actorly communion are breezed past with monotonous banter, as is the fleetingly visible plot." (See all of Nick Pinkerton's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
712 words, 12/14/11

Josh Tyler, Cinema Blend: EXCELLENT (cg)
"The action is intense, the story complex and thrilling, the characters as subtle and nuanced as a good Sherlock Holmes story deserves." (See all of Josh Tyler's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
705 words, 12/15/11

Brett Michel, Boston Phoenix: MODERATE (cg)
"The sequel lacks some of the fun of the first, despite the fact that -- or maybe because -- it adds more explosive action.... elementary, and so is the film's appeal." (See all of Brett Michel's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
153 words, 12/15/11

Keith Phipps, AV Club: MODERATE (cg)
"So many explosions, but it still finds a way to fizzle out." (See all of Keith Phipps's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
397 words, 12/15/11

Jen Yamato, Movieline: VERY GOOD (cg)
"The play between wild-eyed Downey and the serenely unsettling Jared Harris crackles with a chemistry befitting Doyle's iconic literary nemeses..." (See all of Jen Yamato's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
895 words, 12/15/11

Nick Schager, Slant: WEAK (cg)
"Ritchie goes for tedious commotion over cheeky comedy or cleverness in this depressingly flaccid follow-up... mistakes intricacy for mystery at every turn..." (See all of Nick Schager's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
576 words, 12/14/11

Norman Wilner, Toronto Now: GOOD (NOT GREAT) (cg)
"...shit constantly blows up or catches fire... Downey's still miscast as Holmes, but it's less bothersome this time around because we already know what we're in for."
(See all of Norman Wilner's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
174 words, 12/15/11

Edward Adams, Atlanta Creative Loafing: WEAK (cg)
"...gives very little exploration into the man to make us care aside from his ability to constantly confound his nemesis. Ultimately you just go, who cares?" (See all of Edward Adams's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
850 words, 12/16/11

MaryAnn Johanson, Flick Filosopher: EXCELLENT (cg)
"...nice to see a story about male friends that is this fresh and funny and honest.... The fun of finding new things to say about an old story is very much afoot here." (See all of MaryAnn Johanson's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
922 words, 12/13/11

HIGHBROW PRESS (5 Reviews)

Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal: POOR
" 'Hidden within the unconscious is an insatiable desire for conflict,' Moriarty intones at a crucial point.... there's also a desire for coherence and humanity in movies." (See all of Joe Morgenstern's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
212 words, 12/16/11

A.O. Scott, New York Times: FAIR
"Can a movie be hyperactive and lazy at the same time? Clever and idiotic? If the director is Guy Ritchie, the questions answer themselves."
(See all of A.O. Scott's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
497 words, 12/16/11

Andrew Lapin, NPR: WEAK
"Holmes has become a Looney Tune, an exhausting, manic buffoon who keeps almost dying before bouncing, bright and chipper, back to life." (See all of Andrew Lapin's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
593 words, 12/15/11

Betsy Sharkey, Los Angeles Times: GOOD
"...a few shades brighter than its predecessor... closer to the full-throttle 'Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels' mode director Guy Ritchie didn't quite capture the first time."
(See all of Betsy Sharkey's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
764 words, 12/16/11

Andrew O'Hehir, Salon: GOOD (NOT GREAT)
"...occasionally thrilling, sometimes hilarious and mostly absolute claptrap." (See all of Andrew O'Hehir's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
970 words, 12/15/11

MOVIE INDUSTRY (6 Reviews)

Brian Lowry, Daily Variety: VERY GOOD
"...parts of this second 'Sherlock Holmes' are considerably more rewarding... the film sizzles in its quieter moments between Holmes and Moriarty..." (See all of Brian Lowry's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
542 words, 12/08/11

Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter: GOOD (NOT GREAT)
"...an elaborate entertainment that whooshes along through the messy streets and posh clubs of 1891 London... not half-bad." (See all of Todd McCarthy's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
880 words, 12/08/11

Betsy Sharkey, Los Angeles Times: GOOD
"...a few shades brighter than its predecessor... closer to the full-throttle 'Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels' mode director Guy Ritchie didn't quite capture the first time."
(See all of Betsy Sharkey's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
764 words, 12/16/11

Emanuel Levy, Cinema 24/7: GOOD (cg)
"...more of the same, only bigger.... This is pretty much 'James Bond' set in the 1890s.... a more-than-serviceable second time around." (See all of Emanuel Levy's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
670 words, 12/13/11

A.O. Scott, New York Times: FAIR
"Can a movie be hyperactive and lazy at the same time? Clever and idiotic? If the director is Guy Ritchie, the questions answer themselves."
(See all of A.O. Scott's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
497 words, 12/16/11

Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal: POOR
" 'Hidden within the unconscious is an insatiable desire for conflict,' Moriarty intones at a crucial point.... there's also a desire for coherence and humanity in movies." (See all of Joe Morgenstern's reviews...) (Read the full review...)
212 words, 12/16/11
(cg) = based on the critic's grade

Review Mixture
20.5 Percentage Points Average Difference Between Reviews
(Norm is 18.4pp; <18.4pp = More Consistent; >18.4pp = More Mixed)
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows's reviews are separated by an average 20.5 percentage points. The norm for this measure is 18.4 percentage points. Less than 18.4 indicates more consistent reviews; greater than 18.4 indicates more mixed reviews. In the chart below, each dot represents a review, with the dots at the top more positive than the dots at the bottom. From left to right, the dots represent reviews in big, bigger and biggest publications. Roll over each dot for more detail.

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
(49 reviews)
Roll over dots for each review
Broad National   Alternative/Indie   Highbrow Press   Key Cities
NY, LA, Chicago, & Toronto Movie Industry  
Outstanding
Very Good
Good
Moderate
Weak
Poor
Reviews
Outstanding
Very Good
Good
Moderate
Weak
Poor
Reviews
Big
Publications
>Bigger
Publications
>Biggest
Publications
Coverage, Volume & Length
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows

Coverage: Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows's reviews cover 94.6% of potential readers (average is 67.9%). Volume: The film's reviews total 27,348 words in volume (average is 20,194 words). Length: The film's reviews average 558 words in length (the norm is 517 words).

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
Coverage, Volume & Length
(49 Reviews, reviews below)
TotalBroad
National
Press
Local
News-
papers
Alter–
native/
Indie
High-
Brow
Press
Movie
Industry
NY/LA
Chicago
Toronto
Key
Cities
Total
B.O.
Coverage:
Volume:
Length:
94.6%
27,348
558
100.0%
5,541
554
96.4%
12,829
558
100.0%
5,636
564
73.4%
3,036
607
100.0%
3,565
594
100.0%
7,655
547
91.6%
6,662
512
$186.8M
Averages: 67.9%
20,194
517
65.9%
3,293
468
80.7%
10,360
518
82.0%
3,545
448
58.6%
2,460
626
85.2%
3,381
674
84.6%
5,870
497
73.2%
2,799
533
Opening Day Reviews
Reviews Broke 8.9 Hours After Release (Norm is 1.2 Release)
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows's reviews on average broke 8.9 hours after opening. Norm for this measure is 1.2 hours before. The chart below shows reviews on opening day and the days before and after opening; the left side is earlier and the right side is later. The red bars extending above the horizontal mid-line represent more positive reviews, and the red bars extending below represent more negative reviews. The white space/red bar in the middle is Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows's opening day. Click on any bar for a list of the reviews for that day.

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
(49 reviews, click on bars for reviews)
M O R E    P O S I T I V E    R E V I E W S
E
A
R
L
I
E
R
L
A
T
E
R
M O R E    N E G A T I V E    R E V I E W S
Movie Review Intelligence Mobile Web App 1.2
Updated: Sun, Nov 4 2012, 11:24am
Digg This StumbleUpon del.icio.us Twitter Share on Facebook
 | E-Mail to a Friend  | Print 


Mobile Web App version 1.2 shows a list of all current movies and review information. You can click through to the cast, director, synopsis, release date and rating on page two, plus individual reviews on page three. The information is updated on a live/real-time basis. You can also search our database of films. Designed for when you're on the move and want the latest info, this app will work on any mobile web browser.

From your mobile device -- only from a mobile device -- open our Mobile Web App here...


 

get one email
Update
every Friday when
the reviews are in
GO

Opening Soon
   (Early Figures)

Friday, May 24
Fast & Furious 6 78.0% May 24
The Hangover Part III 25.0% May 23
Epic (2013) nr May 24
3 Geezers! 50.0% May 22
A Green Story 25.0% May 24
Alyce Kills 62.5% May 24
Before Midnight (2013) 97.5% May 24
Charge 75.0% May 23
Fill the Void (Lemale et ha'halal) 77.5% May 24
Plimpton! Starring George Plimpton as Himself 67.9% May 22
We Steal Secrets: The Story of Wikileaks 76.7% May 24
Friday, May 31
After Earth nr May 31
Now You See Me (2013) nr May 31
American Mary 66.6% May 31
Hannah Arendt 65.6% May 29
I Do (2013) 54.5% May 31
Shadow Dancer (2013) 73.3% May 31
The East 89.1% May 31
The Kings of Summer 75.0% May 31
Friday, June 7
The Internship (2013) nr Jun 7
The Purge nr Jun 7
Évocateur: The Morton Downey Jr. Movie nr Jun 7
Dirty Wars 83.0% Jun 7
Much Ado About Nothing (2013) 95.6% Jun 7
Passion 53.5% Jun 7
Rapture-Palooza nr Jun 7
Syrup nr Jun 7
Tiger Eyes nr Jun 7
Violet & Daisy 58.0% Jun 7
Wish You Were Here (2013) 72.7% Jun 7
You Ain't Seen Nothin' Yet (Vous n'avez encore rien vu) 71.1% Jun 7
Friday, June 14
This Is the End nr Jun 12
Man of Steel (2013) nr Jun 14
The Bling Ring 66.6% Jun 14
Vehicle 19 25.0% Jun 14
Beyond
Don Jon 55.6% Oct 18
Battle of the Year nr Sep 13
Ain't Them Bodies Saints 86.3% Aug 16
Crystal Fairy 65.0% Jul 12
Fruitvale Station 89.3% Jul 26
I'm So Excited! 54.7% Jun 28
In a World... 81.5% Aug 9
Lovelace 73.5% Aug 9
Prince Avalanche 77.9% Aug 16
The Attack (L'attentat) 62.8% Jun 21
The Hunt (Jagten) 71.3% Jul 12
The Spectacular Now 82.2% Aug 2
The Way, Way Back 87.6% Jul 5
Touchy Feely 61.5% Sep 6
V/H/S/2 68.3% Jul 12
Wadjda 90.1% Aug 30
You Will Be My Son (Tu seras mon fils) 71.3% Sep 13